Muslim masculinity: Why “good man” beats “red pill”

Muslim masculinity: Why “good man” beats “red pill”

August 3, 2026

Listen on:

What does masculinity look like when you’re a Muslim man trying to navigate red pill culture, feminism, and a faith tradition that’s been around for 1,400 years, all at once? On this episode of the Men’s Therapy Podcast, host Marc Azoulay talks with Nabeel Azeez, author of 40 Hadith on Masculinity, who’s spent a decade writing about masculinity from an Islamic lens, first through his old blog and now through muslimman.com. 

Nabeel and Marc trace how red pill ideas have made their way into the Muslim world roughly a decade behind the West, and why some of it resonates even where it clashes with faith. They dig into why so many men, Muslim or not, end up stuck in nice guy syndrome and codependency, mistaking self-erasure for love. Marc breaks down why therapy built for women often doesn’t land for men, and why men grow through challenge instead of connection. Nabeel makes the case that the real question was never “what does a real man look like,” it’s “what does a good man look like,” and that shifting gender roles inside marriage are forcing both cultures to answer it fresh.

Who is this episode for?

This episode is for Muslim men trying to reconcile modern masculinity with their faith, for anyone drawn to red pill ideas but unsure what to keep and what to leave behind, and for men who recognize themselves in nice guy syndrome or codependent relationship patterns. It’s also for partners and therapists curious about how gender roles and stigma around therapy show up differently across cultures.

Why is red pill culture spreading in the Muslim world?

Nabeel explains that globalization and internet culture have closed the gap between Western social movements and the Muslim world, where ideas used to arrive roughly a decade later. Red pill content is catching on for some of the same reasons it did in the West: it offers concrete direction (get in shape, build confidence, handle your finances) at a moment when older messaging tore down traditional roles without replacing them with anything.

What’s the difference between “good man” and “good at being a man”?

Drawing on Jack Donovan’s The Way of Men, Nabeel separates being good at being a man (the tactical virtues, strength, competence) from being a good man (character, ethics). His book reframes Islamic masculinity around the second question, using 40 sayings of the Prophet as the standard, rather than whatever definition of “real man” happens to be trending.

How do nice guy syndrome and codependency show up in men?

Marc describes nice guy syndrome as people-pleasing without boundaries, men trying to do it all domestically and financially because they feel guilty asking for help. Codependency takes it further: tying your emotional state to someone else’s happiness, which he says reads as a powerless, unattractive position rather than a loving one. Both patterns, he argues, quietly build resentment until they surface as withdrawal, addiction, or a hidden second life.

Why is there still stigma around men going to therapy?

Marc traces the shift from an older stigma, therapy is for “broken” people, to a newer one: therapy as a threat or ultimatum from a partner rather than a genuine choice. That framing casts the therapist as an antagonist from the start. He notes men are more likely to stick with it when they trust the provider and work through it in a men’s group rather than alone.

How are gender roles shifting inside marriage?

Both hosts note the same tension playing out in the West and the Muslim world: women earning their own income are reshaping what a husband’s traditional provider role even means. Marc shares his own marriage as an example of assigning domains (he cooks, his wife handles cleaning) by conversation rather than default, while Nabeel points to gender roles in marriage as the single biggest flashpoint between modern life and Islamic tradition.

Where can I find Nabeel Azeez?

Nabeel Azeez can be contacted via his website and Instagram. His media company is called Muslimman. His book is called 40 Hadith on Masculinity: How to be a Good Man.

Ready to go deeper? Men’s Therapy Online offers Individual therapy built specifically for men. Also consider joining the Men’s Group and the free Slack Community where over 250 men have real conversations about growth, identity, and men’s mental health.

——————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————

Disclaimer: MTO connects men with licensed practitioners who provide guidance and support for navigating the challenges of modern life. These coaching services are not a substitute for mental health treatment, emergency services, or crisis support.